Nepal ended 239 years of royal rule last year, making the Shah dynasty the latest monarchy to tumble. Nepal became a republic soon after. The last time a monarchy was abolished was in May 2007 when Samoa’s king died. There are currently 30 monarchs reigning over 44 extant sovereign monarchies in the world. As we have reached the 21st Century, many people now view monarchy as an archaic system and should have no place in modern society. And even the democratic constitutional ceremonial monarchies are very fragile and in threat of their survival. Because in the 21st century, a political institution, monarchy, which has been around since preliterate man, is on the verge of extinction. In an age of democracy, it is hierarchic; in an age of egalitarianism, it is elitist; in an age of skepticism, it is mystical. So tell me, Do You think it’s time for the remaining monarchies of the World to be abolish and if so, why? Please! I want a straight forward yes or no answer and why. And NOT just that "THEY’RE TRADITION THEY SHOULD BE LEFT ALONE" I NEED A BETTER ANSWER THAN THAT!
Can you debunk these arguments, for all monarchies in general, both absolute AND constitutional:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republicanism_in_the_United_Kingdom#Arguments_in_favour_of_a_republic
1. Monarchy is the opposite of democracy
2. Monarchy denies the people a basic right
3. Monarchy devalues a governmental system
4. The monarchy is religiously discriminatory
5. Monarchy is gender-discriminative
6. A monarchy demands deference
7. A monarchy is the enemy of merit and aspiration
8. It devalues intellect and achievement
9. It harms the monarchs themselves
10. Monarchs are not impartial, and lack accountability
11. The monarchy is expensive
12. The monarchy makes the nation look backwards
13. The monarchy doesn’t represent the country and it’s culture
Please, comment on these facts.
And please no "it’s up to the people in these countries to decide" I have heard about these nations, and they want republics. I want to know what YOU think.
You want something abolished? Monarchies are last on the list of governments that need to be destroyed.
1. Hugo Chavez and his tyrannical and certifiably insane dictatorship (he dressed up a parrot in a mock up of his military uniform and had him on his shoulder during a public speech). He "won" the presidency and then added the extension of the term in office to life. He regularly verbally attacks the United States and her allies. He funds terrorist groups.
2. Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and his dictatorship. Known for funding, aiding, and training terrorist groups. Masking an obvious nuclear weapons program with laughable false "giving power to my people" propaganda. Also held the US hostages in the 1970’s, yet denies it even with video, photographic, and eye witness proof. Also known to fix elections to remain in power.
3. Kim Jong Il and his laughable country. Maintains his power without elections. Starves his people as well as test fires missiles that are known to be able to carry nuclear warheads.
4. China’s government which forces women to be sterilized. Limits number of children a family can have. As well know for mass genocide killings, torture and arrests for those who speak freely. Also oppression and torture of those in Taiwan.
Those are just a few that I can name off the top of my head. So before Nepal or whatever you think monarchies need to be abolished. Think about those first. Democracy is the best governmental system to date.